Forum

Writer-Directors re...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Writer-Directors recasting actors

7 Posts
3 Users
3 Likes
31 Views
Get a like on a post Ask a question about Screenwriting Create a Post Like a post Logline Lab Blog
Posts: 42
Topic starter
Trusted Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Hey folks, I have been binging Mike Flanagan's works on Netflix. And, he recasts so many actors in his works, such as his amazing wife, Kate Siegal, Henry Thomas and Carla Gugino. Martin Scorsese does the same thing with Leonardo DiCaprio and Robert DeNiro. 

Why do you think Writer/Directors do this? Would you do this?

Reply
6 Replies
2 Replies
Joined: 1 year ago

Ask a question about Screenwriting TV & Film Analysis Get a like on a post Like a post Create a Post Logline Lab Seminars & Workshops high tech, binary numbers, face-185146.jpg Character Database Podcast Screenplay Library Logline Builder Industry interviews Hollywood Writers & Directors Script Services Live Streams
Estimable Member
Posts: 151

I think as long as the actors are able to embody the rolls I’m totally fine with a director working with people who make the process easier and better. 🙂

Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Get a like on a post Like a post Create a Post Live Streams Seminars & Workshops TV & Film Analysis Hollywood Writers & Directors Screenwriting Gurus Industry interviews Logline Builder Screenplay Library Podcast high tech, binary numbers, face-185146.jpg Character Database Script Services Books Blog Screenwriting Gigs Logline Lab
15% off StoryandPlot.com 30% off at Filmustage.com Manager Contact List
Member
Posts: 280

Great question. I believe it's just like any job you want to work with the people you like, trust, and are talented!

Reply
Get a like on a post Ask a question about Screenwriting Create a Post Like a post Logline Lab Blog
Posts: 42
Topic starter
Trusted Member
Joined: 1 year ago

I agree about the trust, talent, and reliability. But, as an audience, I often have a harder time seeing the role versus seeing the actor.

Also, isn't it a good way to infuse your creativity to work with new actors? Or, with the density with which Flanagan and Scorsese work, maybe it is best to just use actors that know your process rather than breaking in new actors.

I mean, they are masters, at what they do.

Reply
3 Replies
Joined: 1 year ago

Ask a question about Screenwriting TV & Film Analysis Get a like on a post Like a post Create a Post Logline Lab Seminars & Workshops high tech, binary numbers, face-185146.jpg Character Database Podcast Screenplay Library Logline Builder Industry interviews Hollywood Writers & Directors Script Services Live Streams
Estimable Member
Posts: 151

If the actor is good, the hope would be you stop seeing them and see the character they portray instead.

I know it can get to be a bit much if you see them over and over again. 

But for me, I swear, I really felt like Kate Siegel played such different parts in those shows I honestly didn’t recognize her at first.

Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Get a like on a post Ask a question about Screenwriting Create a Post Like a post Logline Lab Blog
Trusted Member
Posts: 42

That’s 100% true for Usher. OMG. She was fantastic!

Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Get a like on a post Like a post Create a Post Live Streams Seminars & Workshops TV & Film Analysis Hollywood Writers & Directors Screenwriting Gurus Industry interviews Logline Builder Screenplay Library Podcast high tech, binary numbers, face-185146.jpg Character Database Script Services Books Blog Screenwriting Gigs Logline Lab
15% off StoryandPlot.com 30% off at Filmustage.com Manager Contact List
Member
Posts: 280

That's a really good point as well! Of course there are always actors out there who are essentially playing themselves in every part. So that doesn't help!

Reply
Share: